Twenty years ago today, my dad died. The cause was prostate cancer. He fought it for years. He refused to stop working, so he went through treatments while shooting “Law And Order.” On the one hand, one could think that was crazy — wouldn’t you want to devote all your strength into battling your illness? On the other hand, his work was so much a part of his identity, that to let go of it might have been letting go of himself. After spending so much of his life in the theater, where camaraderie and teamwork are so important, the idea of not letting the cast, crew, and audience down must have been a big motivator for him. So as a son, I can think “why didn’t you take better care of yourself?” But as an artist, I can think, “At least you didn’t abandon yourself.” It took several years to be able to detach enough from the grief of losing him to be able to make that distinction.
I’d never lost someone that close to me before, and it screwed me up for a long time. Grief makes you completely nuts. And in western society, where we’re SO focused on life, health, and youth, I think a lot of us are probably mentally and spiritually unprepared for illness and death.
The added components of fame and money made an already painful thing a lot more complicated. Things that most other people hash out in private are laid bare in public, often without context and with a lot of misunderstanding.
The main thing is, it took a lot of time to be able to sort things out. But as years — decades — have passed, many of the complicated, negative, and immature resentments I hung onto have fallen away. I’ve said this before — when you have a parent who is a celebrity, you have to share them with the world. When you’re a kid, you think, “I want more of you for me!” But the trade off has been seeing the millions of people around the world that sharing him has brought real joy to. Not just passing pleasure and light entertainment…people genuinely feel better because of his work. I think of how many songs, books, and movies that helped provide context and meaning to times in my life that seemed impossible to navigate.The right song at the right time can make the unbearable bearable. Knowing that my dad’s work continues to make so many people happy makes me happy too. It doesn’t fill the hole of his not having been there at times then, and not being here now…but it’s like a glider that flies me over it. I can see the depth and size of that hole, and also the beauty of the sky above it.
I’m mostly sad that he didn’t see me become more together as a person, and that he’s never met my kids. But he’s also IN me, and in them. When Aaron cracks a silly joke, I see a little bit of dad’s zany gleam. Emily looks TOTALLY like her mom, but when she stands on a box and belts out a song, I think of him standing in a spotlight and hitting the back of the house with his voice. That’s the real legacy. Not who cashes the checks.
He never taught me how to change a tire, or use a chainsaw. But he did show me the importance of being on time, treating your co-workers well, and giving it your best shot. Also how to hold a pool cue.
I also want to share a story — about the time he got the most angry with me.
I think what frustrated him the most about me was my talent for getting in my own way. I didn’t really learn how to sing in public without being a nervous wreck until I was in my forties and fifties. I could open up in the recording studio, but on stage, my voice “hid.”
One day, I was visiting him at his “health” club. I put the word “health” in quotation marks because it was mostly middle aged guys smoking cigars and eating cold cuts while playing cards. But there was a gym there, and I would visit him often and we had great times.
On this one particular day, after working out, we were in the showers, in separate stalls. We would often sing together while showering, sometimes duets and sometimes taking turns. But on this one day my voice was feeling especially good, and I started singing Roy Orbison’s “Crying.” It’s a tough song with some big, open, long, high notes. And I was banging them out with no problem. I hadn’t noticed that he wasn’t laughing or singing along. There was silence. As I was hitting another big note, I was startled to see him in the corner of my eye — he had left his shower stall and was standing, naked, dripping, still covered with soap — suds in his hair and all over his body, and he was holding a back brush like he was going to beat me with it. He looked absolutely LIVID. The anger in his eyes was more intense than I’d ever seen before or since. And then he yelled at me: “HOW THE FUCK ARE YOU HITTING THOSE NOTES??? AND WHY AREN’T YOU OUT THERE SINGING SOMEPLACE???? WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU???”
Back then, I felt a kind of shock around that. But it took me years to unpack that moment. Yes, he was frustrated with me, but also, my god, what a vote of confidence! This was Jerry Freaking Orbach, one of the best singers on Broadway, telling me at 29 that I “had it.” I didn’t really believe it until I was around 53. A connection finally got made, between a shower on 54th street in 1998 and a rehearsal studio in Ogunquit in 2022. I wished he could have seen it.
Some stuff just takes time.